Dublin riots show that the current Garda model of policing is no longer viable

I have repeated on many occasions that the Garda Síochana is not a corporate business. It is a public service, writes retired Garda Sergeant Christy Galligan.
Dublin riots show that the current Garda model of policing is no longer viable

The disengagement of gardaí within their communities because of a policing model and strategy more concerned with statistical performances and a hands-off approach has all but removed the very essence of what it is to be a member of An Garda Siochána. Photo: Sam Boal / © RollingNews.ie

The despicable and uncalled for rioting in Dublin on November 23 was a culmination of many things.

One of those is the disengagement of gardaí within their communities because of a policing model and strategy more concerned with statistical performances and a hands-off approach, rather than allowing the force to do what it was always good at doing, involving itself in communities.

That disengagement was allowed to happen on a large scale. It was started with the closing of garda stations, followed by the amalgamation of divisions and districts, transferring personnel from small to larger stations, tying frontline gardai to computers answering nonsensical queries, and removing District Officers from their roles and responsibilities.

Further disengagement with the local gardaí was the transferring of calls from local stations to call centres.

No longer could you call your local station with a query or complaint, now you were being transferred to a call centre in Galway or Dublin where a person you never met, or are never likely to, will answer your query or complaint. All the while you are waiting for Garda assistance from your local station that might be a hundred yards or more down the road from where you live, if you're lucky.

On top of all this we saw an increasing number of resignations and reduced recruitment, showing a failure of those in charge to listen to the legitimate concerns of garda representative associations, whose members have their ears to the ground, and the legitimate concerns of the citizens of this state, regarding policing and much-needed security.

The present Garda model of policing is no longer viable, it is a wasted and flawed model thought up by people, some former police personnel from other countries who never understood the community model the Garda force had. Picture: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin
The present Garda model of policing is no longer viable, it is a wasted and flawed model thought up by people, some former police personnel from other countries who never understood the community model the Garda force had. Picture: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin

While there are wonderful community police personnel who do trojan work within communities, the corporate strategy of ticking the proverbial box in order to appease Dáil Committees or the Policing Authority has all but removed the very essence of what it is to be a member of An Garda Síochána.

When I first started as a young recruit in Cork City, one of the most valuable lessons I learned from my sergeants and tutors was getting to know as many people within your sphere of work or your patrol beat. 

Be that shopkeepers, postmen, the public, and even members of the criminal fraternity, that knowledge and information that you gained from those interactions was the most valuable tool in your box.

You were also allowed to use discretion, something that is deficient in this present policing model. Common sense played a large part in policing communities but that too unfortunately has taken a back seat. 

Your sources of information and intelligence came from those aforementioned, and many more, when a major incident happened or when something was about to happen.

Now they have so many obstacles put in place regarding information and intelligence gathering that if a garda has information he must go to his CHIS operative and inform them who it is that imparted that information.

The present Garda model of policing is no longer viable, it is a wasted and flawed model thought up by people, some former police personnel from other countries who never understood the community model the Garda force had.

I have repeated on many occasions that the Garda Síochana is not a corporate business. It is a public service.

While corporate strategies may suit companies and businesses, An Garda Síochána was modelled on community engagement and "on the moral authority as servants of the people''.

  • Christy Galligan is a Retired Garda Sergeant

More in this section

Lunchtime News
Newsletter

Keep up with the stories of the day with our lunchtime news wrap.

Sign up
Revoiced
Newsletter

Sign up to the best reads of the week from irishexaminer.com selected just for you.

Sign up
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited