'People tell you that time heals but it doesn’t' - The suffering of families of road traffic victims

Irish Examiner journalist, Jack White, speaks to family members who have lost loved ones to road traffic collisions.

Speed Kills Video by the RSA

Janice Kavanagh was only 10 years old when she was killed by a drunk driver just three weeks before Christmas in 1991.

Although it’s been almost 32 years, her mother Margaret said the pain is everlasting.

“The pain just doesn’t go away. People say time heals; time heals on the outside but not your inside, your heart is just broken,” she said. “There is no point in me saying that time heals.”

/
Victims family members Margret Kavanagh, Robbie Callaghan, Julie Patton, Leo Lieghio and Donna Price pictured at Vigil for Irish road victims at Leinster House Dublin

Margret Kavanagh Left picture at the vigil of Irish road victimcs at Leinster House Dublin, also included other Victims family members (L-R) Robbie Callaghan, Julie Patton, Leo Lieghio and Donna Price Picture Stephen Collins/Collins Photos

icon

She left the house at 6.30pm to go to the shop and within five minutes, all of a sudden she was dead'

Margaret Kavanagh, who lost her daughter Janice

Janice was on the way to a local shop with her friends to buy sweets that evening and although her friends ran across the road, Janice waited for the pedestrian light.

“I knew when they said that she was knocked down that she didn’t go against the lights, because she was that type of child,” she said.

She said Janice was “a dream”, easy-going, and cared deeply for her siblings and her parents. "A van came along and just took her off her feet and took her up 60 yards from the lights."

Ms Kavanagh’s husband was at work that evening and once Janice’s friends knocked at her door to tell her about the incident, she said “not for one minute” did she think that she might have been killed.

“When I ran down I looked at the lights and I just couldn’t believe that she was up the other end of the street,” she said.

Janice died instantly.

Ms Kavanagh said the aftermath was “turmoil” and their lives were turned “upside down”.

icon

And that was on the 5th of December so we had to look to Christmas because we had a 13-year-old and a four-year-old. That was just horrendous.

Ms Kavanagh said she experienced a breakdown five years later, after trying to be strong and going “on and on”, which took its toll.

“I just couldn't cope anymore then,” she said.

She still wakes up every morning and remembers that Janice is missing, and has never parted with any of her belongings.

For Janice’s 40th birthday, her mother recycled her clothes to make teddy bears and hearts for Janice’s friends, who still live in the area and have their own children now.

The drunk driver fled the scene but was caught soon after by a friend of the Kavanaghs who witnessed the collision.

After being found, he told them: “I didn’t do anything.” Ms Kavanagh said he was caught drunk driving again just four months after Janice died.

He was sentenced to five years in prison.

Anatomy of a Split Second Video by the RSA

Motorbike

Patricia Gibbons from Offaly had been married to her husband James for just eight months when he was killed on the morning of January 17, 2008.

Ms Gibbons was five weeks pregnant with their second child at the time.

While at work and after not being able to get through to James, Ms Gibbons said she had “an eerie feeling”.

When her father came to her workplace, she knew something was wrong.

Patricia Gibbons with her sons Conor and David. “Having to tell Conor was so hard.”. Picture Ger Rogers

Patricia Gibbons with her sons Conor and David. “Having to tell Conor was so hard.” Picture Ger Rogers

icon

It was life-changing because our lives were just starting, we were eight months married and we were expecting our second baby, and we were in our house but in a split second everything just changed

Patricia Gibbons, who lost her husband James

James, who was just 28, was driving his lorry to work when another lorry veered into his path and hit him head-on, killing him instantly.

The collision happened in Tipperary, on the Roscrea to Templemore road at Ashmere.

James’ lorry was in working order, Ms Gibbons said, however, the other lorry was not roadworthy, and had bald tyres.

She said James was hardworking and made time for everyone, always offering to help, while having a deep love for his son Conor. 

Patricia Gibbons with her sons Conor and David. “Having to tell Conor was so hard.”. Picture Ger Rogers

Patricia Gibbons with her sons Conor and David. “Having to tell Conor was so hard.” Picture Ger Rogers

icon

Having to tell Conor was so hard. Things will never be the same again. We know that James is never coming back and we just have to learn to get on with it but it's not easy.

Ms Gibbons said she has received immense support from the Irish Road Victims Association (IRVA). ”We’re all part of a group that we don’t want to be part of.” 

IRVA hosts an annual day of remembrance for those who have lost loved ones on Irish roads.

“Every year we have to get more tables to put frames on because there's so many people killed on the roads, so many people's lives altered and changed forever,” she said.

Motorcycle Safety Video by the RSA

Ambulance

There's no punishment out there,” said Leo Lieghio. “There is no excuse, we all know the rules of the road, we all know what the laws and speed limits are.

“If you hit someone and kill them you should be held for premeditated murder because you know you’re speeding, you know you’re drinking or taking drugs and driving.” 

Leo Lieghio, father of road victim Marsia, at a commemorative event for the global ‘World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims’ last year.

Leo Lieghio, father of road victim Marsia, at a commemorative event for the global ‘World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims’ last year. Picture Keith Arkins Media

Mr Lieghio, who lives in Wicklow, lost his daughter Marsia in 2005 when she was just 16.

“When I'm around the kids, I put on a brave face and pretend nothing has happened. But then when I come home on my own I can't help but remember,” he said.

He described his daughter, who wanted to become a midwife, as a “prankster” with an infectious laugh, who would have her friends in stitches.

She was on the way home from a birthday party and was crossing at pedestrian lights when she was struck by a driver who fled the scene.

Marsia was in hospital for a few days when they got the news that there was no blood flowing to her brain. Her mother got physically sick when she heard.

Leo Lieghio holds a photograph of his daughter Marsia at his home near Baltinglass, Co. Wicklow.

Leo Lieghio holds a photograph of his daughter Marsia at his home near Baltinglass, Co. Wicklow. Picture Moya Nolan

It was like someone reaching into your stomach and trying to rip out your guts,” he said.

Nurses gave them a lock of her hair and a palm print before turning off Marsia's life-support machine on her sister Leah’s birthday, while some of her favourite songs were playing.

“She’s gone longer now than we had her with us,” he said.

“People will tell you that time heals but it doesn’t heal at all.

icon

Every day is a struggle and then when you hear the number of people getting killed every day on the roads, everything just keeps coming back.

Leo Lieghio

Mr Lieghio believes those in power are at fault, saying there is “so much that can be done”.

Despite campaigning since Marcia’s death, people will not listen, he said.

“They have to be pushed and they have to be forced to listen and again the Government and the law and the courts have to push it down people's throats,” he said.

“Doubling the fines didn't work. You have to double the penalty points.” Two weeks after Marsia was killed, the same driver hit another girl, aged 18, in Belfast.

The driver was already serving a driving ban when Marsia was killed and received a sentence of 10 months for careless driving.

For more information and support see www.irva.ie.

If you enjoyed this immersive read, you may also like these

Irish Examiner Longread

Copyright Irish Examiner.
Design Jim Coughlan/Tiernan King/ Ivan Rodriguez